Est. Columbus, Ohio
Hand-rolled, boiled, and baked using time-honored techniques — bringing the authentic taste of New York to the heart of Columbus since day one.
Our Story
Sammys New York Bagels was born from a simple conviction: Columbus deserves bagels that taste like they came straight off the streets of New York. Not the soft, squishy kind you find at the supermarket — the real deal. Dense, chewy, with a crust that sings.
Every bagel is hand-rolled, boiled to order, and baked fresh in small batches throughout the day. We source quality ingredients, follow time-honored techniques, and refuse to cut corners. The result is a bagel that holds its shape, delivers on texture, and tastes like something worth making a destination out of.
Every bagel shaped by hand, never mass-produced
Traditional boiling step creates that signature chew
Quality ingredients, generous portions, real flavor
Why Sammys
Every bagel is briefly boiled before baking — that's the step that creates the glossy, chewy crust New York bagels are famous for. We don't skip it.
We bake in batches throughout the day so you're never getting a bagel that sat under a heat lamp since morning. Fresh is a standard, not a slogan.
Our bagels are substantial — properly sized, densely textured, and built to hold whatever you pile on top. No tiny, sad bagels here.
We may make New York bagels, but this is our home. We're invested in the Columbus community and proud to serve our neighbors.
Visit Us
600 N Cassady Ave
Columbus, OH 43219
Mon – Fri 8:00 AM – 6:00 PM
Saturday 8:00 AM – 4:00 PM
Sunday Closed
Contact
Whether you're planning a catering order, have a question about our menu, or just want to say hi — we'd love to hear from you.
